FCCS News & Insights

Great Boards Don’t Do All the Work

By Barb Wilkinson, Senior Board Governance Consultant, FCCS

Download the article here

High-performing boards understand that effective governance extends beyond the boardroom. By delegating detailed work to committees, boards can focus their limited meeting time on strategic issues, key decisions, and oversight. A well-structured committee system is one of the hallmarks of an effective board.

Committees increase efficiency, deepen analysis, and strengthen the board’s ability to govern effectively. Effective committees do not replace the board’s responsibility for governance. Rather, they enable directors to perform deeper analysis, leverage specialized expertise, and return to the board with thoughtful recommendations. The result is a board that spends less time reviewing details and more time discussing strategy, risk, performance, and the future of the organization.

Practical examples of effective board
committees include:

• Audit Committee
• Compensation or Human Capital Committee
• Governance Committee
• Risk Committee
• Technology Committee
• Executive Committee
• Ad Hoc or Task Force Committees
  • Formed for specific purposes such as a CEO search, merger evaluation, strategic partnership review, facility project, or major technology investment. Once the work is completed, the committee is dissolved. Board governance guidance specifically recognizes ad hoc committees for special projects requiring focused attention.

Is Your Board Agenda Filled with Committee Work?

Take a Discerning Look at Your Agenda: Strategy Takes Time

Boards often say they want to spend more time on strategy, yet agenda design can unintentionally consume valuable meeting time. Consider the following questions:

Do Committee Reports Regularly Require Board Action?

If committee reports are primarily informational and do not require discussion or action, consider providing them as written reports in the board packet. This allows directors to review the information in advance while preserving meeting time for strategic discussions and decision making.

How Much Time is Spent Revisiting Issues Already Discussed in Committee?

When board meetings repeatedly revisit matters that were thoroughly discussed at the committee level, it may indicate one of two underlying issues:

1. Committees may not have sufficient authority or trust to reach conclusions.
   Clarify the decision-making responsibilities of committees versus the full board. When committees are empowered to do their work effectively, the board can focus on key recommendations and decisions rather than redoing committee discussions.
2. Committee membership may not align with director interests or expertise.
   If a director consistently uses board meeting time to ask detailed questions that were addressed in committee, consider whether that director would be better positioned to serve on the committee itself. Placing directors where they can engage deeply in the work often leads to more efficient and informed board discussions.

Every minute spent rehashing committee work is a minute not spent discussing the future. Strategic governance requires intentional agenda design that prioritizes forward-looking conversations.

Keeping Your Agendas Strategic Takes Discipline

Before your next board meeting, take a discerning look at the agenda and give your board a score on how effectively it protects time for strategic discussion.

Ask yourself:

• Are committee reports consuming time that could be devoted to strategic issues?
• Are directors revisiting topics that have already been thoroughly discussed in committee?
• Is the board focused on the future, or spending most of its time reviewing information and operational details?

Score your agenda honestly. If committee reports and routine business are crowding out strategic conversations, use that insight as a catalyst for change. Engage the board chair and appropriate staff in a discussion about how agenda design, committee authority, and reporting practices can better support the board’s long-term governance responsibilities.

Resources

FCCS’ Board & Director Education

FCCS’ Board Governance Effectiveness